McKinsey Vs BCG Vs Bain: Who Pays MBAs The Highest Salary?

Consulting is a big draw among MBA graduates next only to Finance and with the firms experiencing a 12%-18% increase in revenue in 2015, salaries are on the rise. But which firms pays the highest?

Salaries in consulting are rising. With a base pay pegged at $140,000, starting packages are often in the $170,000-$210,000 range.

MBAs with 2-3 years experience are earning $250,000-$350,000. It could climb up to $350,000-$500,000 in 4-5 years as they move into the ranks of associate principals and senior project leaders.

5 Minute GMAT Score Predictor

Junior partners and principals draw $500,000 to $1 million, while senior partners and directors get anywhere from $1 million to $10 million with 10-15 years of experience.

Consulting industry growth has benefited even freshers grossing anywhere from $80,000 to $100,000 a year after earning their bachelor’s degree. Consultants who transition to the corporate world often generate a 10%-20% raise for themselves.

So, which consulting firms would be the best to work for?

The big three are McKinsey, Bain, and the Boston Consulting Group. All three offer intensive training, high profile clients, and benefits. Surprisingly, when it comes to overall pay, they do not rank among the top three. This was the finding of a survey by ‘Management Consulted‘, a website that provides education, interview skills and resume coaching to potential consultants.

Which firms are the best paymasters?

Deloitte is on the top with a total package of $228,000 to start. Its $147,000 average base is on level with Boston Consulting Group (BCG) and ahead of McKinsey ($145,000) and Bain ($140,000).
It is also tied with KPMG and Parthenon-EY for the best sign on bonus ($35,000). However, its performance bonus at $36,750 is well below BCG, Accenture, and A.T. Kearney.

But Deloitte provides up to $10,000 for re-location expenses (though local moves only get $2,500). The firm, In recent years, has embarked on an aggressive strategy to take on the big three.

It managed to rise to fourth in Vault’s 2016 consulting rankings, filling the void left by erstwhile Booz & Company.

Meanwhile, Deloitte gets ranked among the top four consulting firms in 10 categories in the Vault ranking of The Best Consulting Companies To Work For, only matched by McKinsey (with BCG and Bain ranking in the top four in seven and four categories respectively).

But then, Deloitte has perception issues. Based on responses from over 9,000 consulting professionals, it was ranked 24th in benefits and 25th in compensation in the 2016 Vault survey.

It ranked 19th when respondents were asked about the long-term outlook for the firm. Thus, the company seems to be paying a premium to attract top talent.

Ranking second at $223,500 in overall compensation is A.T. Kearney, attempting to double the size as part of its Vision 2020 initiative. It pays $10,000 less in the signing bonus ($25,000) than Deloitte, but offers nearly $7,000 more in performance bonus.

5 Minute GMAT Score Predictor

Accenture, with nearly an identical starting package as A.T. Kearney, is also at the top.

BCG ranks fourth overall at $219,000 in total compensation, slightly above sixth-ranked McKinsey ($214,000) and nearly $20,000 higher than Bain ($200,000).

In terms of base, BCG offers $2,000 more than McKinsey and $5,000 above Bain. All three peg sign on bonuses at $25,000.

However, BCG gives more performance bonus than the other two ($42,000 vs. $35,000 for McKinsey and Bain).

The highest base salaries are at Parthenon EY, which pays $170,000 on an average.

Like Deloitte, Parthenon’s higher pay is likely to be tied to market perception, with the firm not even ranked among the top 25 in terms of benefits and long-term outlook in Vault’s survey.

It also fares poorly in formal training (25th), employee satisfaction (20th), supervisor relationships (19th), and vacation policies (17th).

However, it still ranks well in terms of ability to challenge (7th) and firm culture (12th), indicators that workload, not culture, are behind some of the firm’s low marks.

Although Parthenon EY signing bonuses are tied for being the highest ($35,000), its performance bonuses (up to $9,000) are the lowest on Management Consulted’s list.

However, the data is far from perfect. Management Consulted says that only the top 5%-10% of consultants receive the full performance bonus, with the average bonus falling between $18,000 and $20,000.